Hello dear
Welcome To Straight From New York Pizza
Straight From New York Pizza is a culinary gem located in Salem, Oregon, specializing in authentic New York-style pizza. With a menu boasting a variety of whole pies—like the classic Cheese and innovative Cypress Hill—each features housemade marinara and high-quality ingredients, ensuring delicious flavor with every bite. Customers rave about the spacious, inviting atmosphere and delightful service, with many praising the generous portion sizes and value. Whether indulging in a family-sized pizza or a fresh salad, diners appreciate the attention to detail and craftsmanship in each dish. This spot is a must-visit for anyone craving true New York pizza!
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Cheese Pizza
US$16.00Caesar Salad
US$5.50Veggie Pizza
US$29.00
Greek Pizza
US$29.00Meat Lovers Pizza
US$28.00Cheese Pizza Slice
US$3.50
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
US$3.75Vegetarian Pizza Slice
US$4.25Chef's Choice
US$4.25 About
Straight From New York Pizza
Welcome to Straight From New York Pizza, where the authentic taste of New York meets the heart of Salem, Oregon. Nestled at 1095 Commercial St SE, this pizza haven specializes in crafting delicious, high-quality pies that transport you straight to the bustling streets of New York City.
At Straight From New York Pizza, every bite tells a story. Their menu features a mouthwatering selection of pizzas, from classic Cheese Pizza to the savory Cypress Hill Pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, and olives. Each 18" whole pie is baked to perfection, combining housemade marinara sauce and real whole milk mozzarella cheese, ensuring an unforgettable experience for both pizza aficionados and casual diners alike.
What really sets this pizzeria apart is their commitment to quality ingredients. Customers rave about the rich and flavorful crust, a testament to their careful sourcing and expert preparation. As one satisfied diner, Blaine Pardun, noted, "You can tell they care about their pies and take extreme care in the ingredients they use."
The atmosphere at Straight From New York Pizza is just as inviting as their menu. With a spacious and comfortable setting, families and friends can gather to enjoy everything from the popular 2 slices and a soda special to a vibrant chef's choice slice, making this a perfect spot for casual dining or a quick bite. Customers like Tina Loyd appreciate the phenomenal deals, mentioning that their 2 slices and a soda for under $10 is a particularly delightful find.
Not only does Straight From New York Pizza serve outstanding pizza, but their reviews highlight exceptional service as well. Whether you’re bringing your children for a casual meal or stopping by for a quick lunch, the friendly staff are always ready to ensure a pleasant experience. As one patron described, their servers even go above and beyond to help, making your visit memorable.
Your visit to Salem wouldn’t be complete without a stop at Straight From New York Pizza. From the deliciously crafted pies to the atmosphere filled with warmth and hospitality, it’s a slice of New York you won’t want to miss. So grab a slice, sit back, and let the delightful flavors take you on a culinary journey right from the heart of New York.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great pizza for the whole family! We did a make your own and it was a hit. An 18” was plenty big for a family of four. Excellent, speedy service with a great vibe and delicious, high-quality pizza. We got the chicken bacon ranch/plain cheese. ”
“ Absolutely amazing and delicious! I love their 2 slices and a soda for 9 deal. And I tried the breadstick for the first time today and OMG, I have been missing out on a piece of heaven. The server/clerk even went above and beyond and offered to carry my order out because my hands were full with a crying baby. I will definitely be back and I highly recommend !!! ”
“ Straight From New York Pizza has awesome pizza! Me and my girlfriend both hot the slice and salad combo. Katy also got a can of rose wine and said it was very tasty. The salad bowl was amazing! The service was excellent. Highly recommended when your in Salem Oregon! ”
“ This location of Straight from New York Pizza is spacious and comfortable. The pizza was excellent and the garden salad had so many toppings including cheese, green pepper, olives, and many others. What a great price too for pizza and salad combination. Definitely going again soon! ”
“ It's one of the best pizza joints I've eaten at since leaving New York. Always amazing and perfectly cooked crust, toppings are well sourced and top notch. You can tell they care about their pie's and take extreme care in the ingredients they use. ”
“ The best pizza in South Salem. I found this shop on Liberty & Owen, two years ago, driving home from picking up my pups from the kennel. You can order whole pies, salads, wings - but I love the convenience of getting a big slice from one of their many freshly cooked pies that are ready for takeout, or to eat inside at a table or outside at a picnic table. A great treat after seeing a flick at our ‘Salem Theatre’. Highly recommend! ”
“ Top thin crust in town. Have been coming for years. Recommend their pepperoni and chefs choice. I also tried their Chicken bacon pizza and it was creamy and delicious. The spicy chicken has the perfect amount of spice. Very flavorful. ”
“ This may be the best pizza available in Salem. Nice big slices. If all you want is a slice. It's not cheap like a Little Caesars Pizza but it doesn't taste like a Little Caesars Pizza either! ”